GS 3> > Science and Technology > Energy > Nuclear energy
REFERENCE NEWS:
In her Budget 2024 speech, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman announced the development of Bharat Small Reactors (BSRs) as a key initiative to expand India's nuclear energy capabilities.
BHARAT SMALL REACTORS (BSRS):
Bharat Small Reactors (BSRs) are compact nuclear reactors designed to generate electricity on a smaller scale compared to traditional large nuclear power plants.
These reactors aim to make nuclear power more accessible and versatile.
Bharat Small Reactors (BSRs) are India's indigenous response to the global trend of developing small modular reactors (SMRs), sharing similarities in size, modularity, and safety but distinguished by their basis in existing Indian nuclear technology.
BSRs are based on India's existing pressurized heavy water reactor (PHWR) technology, specifically the 220 MW reactors that are already operational in the country. This makes BSRs distinct from many SMRs, which are often entirely new designs.
At the Madras Atomic Power Station in Kalpakkam, Tamil Nadu, India has been operating two 220 MW nuclear power facilities for nearly 40 years. One of these reactors is undergoing repairs, and the other is set to become the first Bharat Small Reactor (BSR).
The government plans to partner with the private sector to set up BSRs and conduct research and development on small modular reactors and newer nuclear technologies.
Small Modular Reactors (SMRs)
SMRs are significantly smaller than traditional nuclear reactors, with a capacity to produce up to 300 MW of electricity. Their modular design allows for faster construction and deployment.
Significance of Bharat Small Reactors (BSRs) with Multiple Dimensions
Boosting Energy Security and Economic Growth:
BSRs are poised to enhance India’s energy security by providing a reliable and continuous power supply.
Unlikerenewable sources likesolar and wind, which are intermittent, nuclear energy can supply baseload power essential for the country’s growing energy needs. This is crucial for meeting the growing energy demands of India’s expanding economy.
"Baseload power" refers to the minimum amount of continuous, reliable power supply that is needed to meet the electricity demands of a grid or region at all times, regardless of seasonal or daily fluctuations.
Private Sector Participation and Policy Shift:
Allowing the private sector to develop and deploy BSRs is a significant policy change. Previously, India's nuclear sector, governed by the Atomic Energy Act of 1962, restricted private involvement.
This change invites private investment, innovation, and expertise, expected to accelerate technological advancements and project timelines. The Tata Group’s collaboration with BARC and the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research exemplifies the potential impact of this engagement.
Contribution to Net Zero Goals:
India has committed to achieving net-zero carbon emissions by 2070. Increasing the share of nuclear energy through BSRs is a vital strategy in this transition. As of July 2023, nuclear power accounts for only 2.8% of the total electricity generation in the country (Source: Department of Atomic Energy).
By scaling up the deployment of BSRs, India can significantly reduce its reliance on fossil fuels, thereby decreasing greenhouse gas emissions. This move aligns with global efforts to combat climate change and supports India’s commitment to sustainable development?.
Technological Advancements and Global Trends:
The development of BSRs aligns with the global trend of adopting small modular reactors (SMRs).This alignment ensures that India stays at the forefront of nuclear technology and benefits from international innovations and collaborations?.
Faster Construction and Lower Costs:
The modular design allows for faster construction, reducing the typical period from 6-12 years for large reactors to 3-5 years for BSRs. The estimated cost of constructing BSRs ranges from USD1-3 billion USD, compared to USD6-12 billion USD for larger reactors?.
Enhanced Safety:
BSRs incorporate advanced safety features, including passive safety systems, which enhance their safety profile compared to traditional reactors. They also require a smaller emergency planning zone, making them safer for nearby populations?.
Remote and Industrial Areas:
Their smaller size and modular nature make BSRs suitable for remote regions and industrial sites that require reliable power but lack the infrastructure for large nuclear plants. This can help in providing power to underserved areas and industries like steel and cement that need consistent and substantial power supply?.
Phased Construction and Scalability:
The modular approach allows for phased construction, enabling operators to add units as demand increases. This scalability helps utilities better match supply with demand and manage financial risks
CHALLENGES AND CONCERNS:
Innovation and Reliability:
Developing reliable and safe BSRs requires significant technological innovation. While India has experience with pressurized heavy water reactors (PHWRs), adapting this technology for smaller, modular reactors involves overcoming new engineering and design challenges.
Additionally, with only one SMR operational in China and another in Russia, SMR technology is still largely under development globally, posing further uncertainties and technological hurdles?.
Regulatory Framework:
The current regulatory framework, governed by the Atomic Energy Act of 1962, needs to be updated to accommodate the development and deployment of BSRs, especially considering the involvement of the private sector. This includes establishing clear guidelines for safety, construction, and operation?.
Safety Concerns:
Ensuring the safety of BSRs is paramount. Historical apprehensions associated with nuclear energy heighten the need for strict safety protocols? .
Nuclear Waste Management:
Managing nuclear waste generated by BSRs poses significant challenges. Effective solutions for the long-term storage and disposal of radioactive waste must be developed to mitigate environmental and health risks?.
Cost Overruns and Delays:
Historically, nuclear projects have been prone to cost overruns and delays. Ensuring that BSR projects remain on schedule and within budget requires meticulous planning and execution.
This is particularly pertinent as India’s last major announcement on nuclear energy in 2017, approving the construction of ten 700 MW traditional reactors, has seen none of those reactors become operational yet?.
High Initial Costs:
Despite being potentially more cost-effective than larger reactors, the initial capital investment required for developing BSRs is still substantial. Securing financing for these projects, especially in the private sector, can be challenging?
Market Dynamics:
Competing with other energy sources, particularly rapidly advancing renewable technologies, could impact the economic viability of BSRs. The market dynamics of energy pricing and demand will play a crucial role in determining the success of BSRs?
Public Acceptance:
Gaining public acceptance for nuclear projects is a significant challenge, given the historical apprehensions associated with nuclear energy. Efforts must be made to educate the public about the safety and environmental benefits of BSRs to build trust and support?
WAY FORWARD:
Strengthen Technological Capabilities:
Invest in advanced research and development to adapt PHWR technology for modular reactors.
Engage in international collaborations with countries that have operational SMRs, such as China and Russia, to accelerate development.
Update Regulatory Framework:
Revise the Atomic Energy Act of 1962 to accommodate BSRs and involve the private sector.
Establish clear guidelines for safety, construction, and operation.
Ensure Economic and Financial Viability:
Provide financial incentives like subsidies and low-interest loans to attract private sector investment.
Implement meticulous planning to keep projects on schedule and within budget, avoiding delays seen in the 2017 reactor project?.
Enhance Public Acceptance and Awareness:
Launch public engagement campaigns to educate about the safety and environmental benefits of BSRs.
Integrate BSRs into the energy market to highlight their role in providing reliable baseload power.
Position BSRs as a cost-effective and scalable solution compared to intermittent renewable energy sources.
Adopt Global Trends and Technological Advancements:
Align BSR development with global trends in SMRs and incorporate international innovations.
Aim for faster deployment and meeting growing energy demands efficiently through modular design.
PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q. What are Bharat Small Reactors (BSRs) and discuss their potential significance for India's energy security and economic growth? (10 marks, 150 words)